Report

Consumer Protection and E-Commerce

Issues for developing country policy-makers

This policy primer aims to support policy-makers in developing countries by providing an overview of key consumer protection issues in the digital marketplace and an understanding of the role of trade agreements on consumer policy matters.

July 10, 2025

Key Messages

  • Traditional consumer protection frameworks, designed for physical marketplaces, must be significantly updated to address the unique challenges of e-commerce, including information asymmetry, data privacy concerns, and cross-border jurisdictional and enforcement issues.

  • Countries are modernizing national consumer protection laws to foster trust in the digital economy. Increasingly, consumer protection–related provisions are also being embedded in trade agreements, especially RTAs, and are an important feature of the potential plurilateral e-commerce JSI agreement.

  • Many developing countries lack modern consumer protection laws for e-commerce. As these countries update their frameworks, key priorities include accommodating technology-driven business models, addressing cross-border transaction challenges, and establishing effective dispute resolution mechanisms.

The digital marketplace is rapidly reshaping global commerce, offering significant opportunities for businesses and consumers alike. In 2023, the global business-to-consumer e-commerce market was valued at USD 5.47 trillion and is projected to rise at a compound annual growth rate of approximately 19% through 2030. However, this growth also presents emerging challenges—particularly for developing countries seeking to participate effectively in the global digital economy. Central to addressing these challenges is the need to build consumer trust through robust consumer protection frameworks. 

The policy primer introduces foundational consumer rights and principles, explores their evolution in digital contexts, and examines the integration of online consumer protection provisions in trade agreements, including regional trade agreements (RTAs) and the World Trade Organization Joint Statement Initiative (JSI) on Electronic Commerce. The paper also highlights the current state of consumer protection policies and challenges in developing countries, concluding with practical recommendations to guide policy-making in this area.

This report is part of a policy primer series, funded by the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA), aimed at deepening understanding of the key policy and regulatory foundations that shape today's digital economy.

This is the first report of the Building Blocks of Digital Trade Regulation series. You can continue exploring the series here:

Report details

Topic
Trade
Project
Digital Trade
Impact area
Sustainable Economies
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD, 2025
Report

World Trade Organization Talks on Additional Fisheries Subsidy Rules

What's on the table now?

Following the adoption of the landmark Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies in 2022, members of the World Trade Organization (WTO) are now negotiating additional global rules to more effectively address the role of subsidies in overfishing. This update outlines the draft provisions under consideration and emphasizes key sustainability considerations for the ongoing negotiations.

July 9, 2025

World governments adopted the historic Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies in 2022 at the WTO's 12th Ministerial Conference. This landmark deal prohibits fisheries subsidies where they pose the greatest threat to sustainability. Building on that foundation, WTO members are now working to strengthen the agreement through additional disciplines aimed at tackling subsidies that encourage overfishing and overcapacity more broadly. 

The aim of these proposed rules is to ensure that government financial support to the fishing industry does not drive unsustainable levels of fishing. If adopted, these disciplines could play a vital role in safeguarding marine ecosystems and supporting the livelihoods, food security, and development prospects of communities that rely on healthy fish stocks. Despite falling short of finalizing these new rules in 2024, members made significant progress and came closer than ever to consensus on this vital sustainable development priority. 

As discussions continue, this update offers an overview of the rules under negotiation, as reflected in the latest draft text circulated by Ambassador Gunnarsson of Iceland, chair of the WTO's Rules Negotiating Group, in November 2024. The update first reviews recent developments in the negotiations and the current state of play, then provides a concise explanation of the new disciplines being proposed. It also includes contextual insights to help readers understand the rationale behind specific provisions. For each main element of the proposed disciplines, summary boxes are included to highlight key features. The update concludes by drawing attention to several important sustainable development considerations related to the draft text.

Report

Guidance on Border Carbon Adjustment

Results of the Global Stakeholder Dialogues

The report provides guidance on border carbon adjustment (BCA) that respects development and climate objectives as well as developing country perspectives. It was created by a multistakeholder group of experts to balance trade, climate, and development goals.

July 8, 2025

Key Messages

  • BCA regimes should demand actual data on greenhouse gases embodied in goods but should also allow for the use of non-punitive default values, ensuring interoperability of measurement requirements with other BCA regimes.

  • Explicit carbon prices, such as those paid under carbon taxes and emissions trading systems in the exporting country, should be credited under BCA regimes, but non-price-based regulatory costs should not be credited.

  • There should not be country-based exemptions for the coverage of a BCA. That is, whole economies should not be exempted from coverage. However, those most affected by the regime should get special treatment in the form of transition periods and dedicated transition support.

  • Any goods to be covered by a BCA should also be covered by a domestic regime of carbon pricing—there should be parallel treatment to the extent possible.

BCA is a hot topic in global trade and climate policy, driven in part by the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism coming into force, and with similar regimes pending in the United Kingdom and Norway. Additionally, BCA is increasingly being explored in other countries such as Australia, Canada, Chinese Taipei, and the United States. 

If adopted in multiple countries, BCA would have major impacts not only on climate ambition but also on trade flows and development prospects. Yet there is no internationally agreed upon guidance on how to design and implement BCA in a way that advances both climate and development objectives. This leaves national policy-makers creating BCA regimes without a shield to defend against domestic vested interests and leaves affected countries and firms without a yardstick by which to assess proposed BCA regimes. 

This guidance—the product of in-country research and consultation in five countries and more than a year of deliberation by a diverse global group of experts—aims to fill that gap. It offers detailed recommendations on BCA design questions, such as:

  1. How to measure greenhouse gas emissions embodied in goods?
  2. What goods and emissions to cover?
  3. What to do with the revenues?
  4. Whether and how to credit carbon prices paid in the country of export?
  5. Whether and how to adjust the carbon price for exports?
  6. What special treatment and exemptions should be granted?

Participating experts

Report

State of Transition

How state-owned power companies can drive energy transition in emerging economies

State-owned power companies (SPCs) can play a critical role in clean energy transition, particularly in emerging markets and developing economies. This report includes case studies from a major SPC in each of India, Indonesia, South Africa, and Viet Nam. Each SPC has made strides in a specific element of energy transition that inform the recommendations for other SPCs, governments, and the international community.

July 8, 2025

Key Messages

  • The energy transition creates important opportunities for SPCs in emerging economies to diversify their business models and advance broader national goals of energy security, electrification, and socio-economic development.

  • Governments need to support SPC efforts in energy transition, including through enabling visionary SPC leadership, developing the required legal frameworks, and shifting public financial support from fossil fuels to clean energy.

  • SPCs need to collaboratively develop energy transition plans that include just transition principles from the outset, are context specific, align with national objectives, and address international and domestic financing solutions.

  • SPCs in emerging economies are often saddled with large debt and difficulties in mobilizing capital. The international finance community should partner with SPCs to design new, innovative options for fast fund disbursement in return for demonstrable progress on decarbonization.

The report investigates how SPCs can lead in energy transition initiatives. To date, discussions on this role have favoured developed economy examples. The report aims to address this gap by analyzing the dynamics of decarbonization facing four of the world’s largest SPCs (outside of China), focusing each case study on one specific element of energy transition. The case studies are: 1) Eskom in South Africa on just energy transition initiatives, 2) NTPC in India on deployment of renewable energy, 3) Vietnam Electricity (EVN) in Viet Nam integrating renewable energy generation, and 4) Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN) in Indonesia on early retirement of coal power plants.

Report details

Report

Market Trends and Potential Benefits of Eco-Certification to Inform Manitoba Commercial Fisheries

Several commercial fisheries in Manitoba are looking to eco-certify, and these fisheries sell their fish primarily to international markets. In this report we analyze European and U.S. market trends in the certified sustainable fish and seafood sector with the goal of unpacking the implications for Manitoba commercial fishers. In addition, we provide resources and recommendations for communicating this important information to fishers.

July 3, 2025

Recommendations

  • Facilitate networking connections between fishers and potential buyers interested in eco-certified fish, maximizing the interest and benefits of obtaining eco-certification.

  • Within the European market, prioritize relationships with buyers in northwestern Europe, where the market is growing the most quickly.

  • Grow the awareness of fishers around current market trends, both now and in the future, to help them make more informed business decisions.

  • Increase discussions between decision-makers—especially at the federal level—and fishers. Fishers need more opportunities to communicate their insights and ideas to the relevant elected officials.

Manitoba's fisheries supply fish to domestic and international markets. While 20% of Manitoban fish is consumed within Canada, 80% goes to international markets, predominantly the United States and Europe. The present report analyzes European and U.S. market trends in the certified sustainable fish and seafood sector with the goal of unpacking the implications for Manitoba commercial fishers. Additionally, it provides guidance on how to communicate the benefits of eco-certification to Manitoba commercial fishers. 

This report builds on the International Institute for Sustainable Development’s 2024 report, The Case of Eco-Certification in Manitoba’s Commercial Fisheries, which reviewed the potential benefits of pursuing eco-certification for Manitoba's commercial freshwater fisheries. It concluded that Manitoba's commercial fisheries stand to benefit both directly and indirectly from acquiring eco-certification, with the direct benefits being greater for larger fisheries. Specifically, it identified the following market benefits for eco-certification:

  1. Eco-certification can lead to an avoided loss of markets valued at CAD 250 for every CAD 1 invested for large lakes, or CAD 16 for every CAD 1 invested for small lakes. This means that for every CAD 1 invested in eco-certifying a fishery, CAD 16 of that fisheries' value is protected from market loss.
  2. Eco-certification provides a greater opportunity for brand building for Manitoba fisheries as a sustainable option for the eco-conscious consumer.
  3. Eco-certified lakes tend to have more stable fish stocks over the long term and are less vulnerable to stock collapse. This makes the supply of fish to markets more reliable. 

This follow-up report aims to elaborate by examining market trends at the consumer end of the supply chain in both the United States and Europe, thereby providing further information on the potential benefits of eco-certification for fisheries. This is an important point to address because 80% of Manitoba's fish is sold to international markets, especially in the United States and Europe.

Report details

Report

Progressing National SDG Implementation 2024

Advancing global goals in an increasingly multipolar world: Unpacking a year of mixed SDG progress

The bulk of Voluntary National Review (VNR) reports submitted by countries to the United Nations in 2024 sounded the alarm on slow progress across many Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), with the climate crisis as well as rising poverty and social inequality being singled out as key areas of concern.

June 26, 2025

Key Messages

  • Multi-stakeholder collaboration is essential but uneven: While partnerships across sectors are increasing, many remain ad hoc or poorly coordinated, with limited visibility into who is involved, the nature of power dynamics among actors, and their concrete outcomes.

  • Civil society adds vital local knowledge and accountability: CSOs are central to localization, monitoring, and advocacy, but often face funding and access barriers that limit their impact.

  • Youth and academia are driving innovation and awareness: Young people and academic institutions bring energy, ideas, and evidence-based insights, but need to be integrated in a more structured way in decision-making processes.

  • Parliamentary action is growing but must deepen: While legislatures are increasingly embedding SDGs in law and budget processes, political dynamics and limited capacity still pose challenges in many countries.

Many countries noted continuing challenges in maintaining SDG momentum due to the lingering effects of conflicts, climate impacts, and economic instability. The two first-time VNR presentations in 2024 were by South Sudan and Yemen, both grappling to rebuild their economies and fragile governance following years of conflict and humanitarian crises. 

While it is not designed to provide a comprehensive review of official reports, this annual "fact-check" by a coalition of civil society organizations (CSOs) aims to support more iterative and accountable SDG monitoring and review processes. Progressing National SDG Implementation highlights where countries are making steady gains, while also identifying remaining gaps and challenges in achieving SDG aspirations, especially from a social inclusion perspective. As such, this report aims to contribute to joint learning by both governments and non-state actors on how to contribute to transformative change while leaving no one behind. 

This report is published in partnership between Action for Sustainable Development, the Arab NGO Network for Development, Bond, CSO Partnership for Sustainable Development, Cooperation Canada, Forus, the International Institute for Sustainable Development, Save the Children, and Sightsavers.

Watch the publication launch webinar

Report details

Topic
Governance and Multilateral Agreements
Sustainable Development Goals
Project
Earth Negotiations Bulletin
Impact area
International Governance
Publisher
Action for Sustainable Development
Copyright
Action for Sustainable Development, 2025
Report

Manitoba's Hudson Bay Lowlands

Ecosystem goods and services valuation

Covering nearly 10% of the province of Manitoba, the Hudson Bay Lowlands provides immense social, economical, and ecological values. Conserving large areas of this region would significantly advance the provincial government's commitment to increase protected lands and waters for future generations, a critical step in tackling climate change and biodiversity loss.

June 25, 2025

Key Findings

  • Through the value of biodiversity conservation, hunting, tourism, and mental health, the Hudson Bay Lowlands provides at least CAD 247.7 million in economic value to the province of Manitoba and beyond.

  • Home to one of the largest wetland and peatland systems globally, the region plays a crucial role through carbon storage, with an estimated 7 billion tonnes of soil organic carbon stored in Manitoba alone—a value of CAD 1.2 trillion.

  • Conserving areas of this region, which covers nearly 10% of Manitoba’s landmass, would significantly advance governments' commitments of protecting at least 30% of terrestrial and inland water areas by 2030, while ensuring equitable governance and respecting the rights of Indigenous Peoples.

  • The Lowlands are not only ecologically significant—they are also culturally vital. Five Indigenous nations are working to conserve a vast expanse of this region as an Indigenous Protected Area and to safeguard their lands, waters, and ways of life.

The Hudson Bay Lowlands is partially located in northeastern Manitoba, encompassing 67,000 square kilometres, which is nearly 10% of the province. This region is one of the world’s most ecologically intact landscapes and provides millions in economic value every year. The region also holds immense value due to its rich Indigenous heritage, globally significant carbon stocks, and diverse wildlife, making it an excellent candidate for conservation. 

The Hudson Bay Lowlands provides nearly CAD 250 million in ecosystem goods and services per year through the value of biodiversity conservation, hunting, tourism, and mental health benefits. This vast landscape also stores an estimated 7 billion tonnes of soil organic carbon (a value of CAD 1.2 trillion)—and that's just in Manitoba.

 

Report details

Topic
Climate Change Adaptation
Nature-Based Solutions
Water
Impact area
Climate
Sustainable Economies
Nature
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD, 2025
Report

Design Choices for Debt Sustainability

From a rules-based approach to a constrained discretion regime

Emerging markets confront increasing fiscal pressures amid rising debt costs and constrained fiscal space. Current rigid fiscal rules often lead to complexity and instability. This report recommends a flexible, regime-based framework that enhances transparency, accountability, and debt sustainability, aiming to improve fiscal management and resilience in developing economies.

June 24, 2025

Policy Recommendations

  • Replace rigid debt rules with flexible debt anchors designed to ensure long-term sustainability while allowing for temporary deviations to address shocks.

  • Embed anchors in a broader fiscal policy regime, incorporating goals, fiscal strategies, and independent evaluations to build a cohesive framework that balances fiscal discipline with adaptability.

  • Enhance transparency and accountability, requiring governments to outline clear policy strategies, communicate future fiscal intentions, and disclose relevant data to strengthen market and public confidence.

  • Leverage independent institutions, establish fiscal councils or similar bodies to assess fiscal risks, advise policy-makers, and ensure fiscal strategies align with debt sustainability objectives.

Emerging markets and developing economies are navigating a complex fiscal landscape marked by rising debt costs and shrinking fiscal space. Traditional rules-based frameworks, once seen as the cornerstone of fiscal discipline, are increasingly showing their limitations. Their rigidity stifles flexibility, while overlapping rules create confusion and inefficiencies. 

This report offers a rethink: moving beyond rigid debt rules to embrace flexible debt anchors that safeguard long-term sustainability without sacrificing the ability to respond to shocks. By embedding these anchors within a comprehensive fiscal regime (complete with clear objectives, strategic planning, and independent oversight), governments can build a more resilient, coherent framework. Enhanced transparency and accountability are central to restoring market and public trust, while independent institutions like fiscal councils play a crucial role in guiding policy toward sustainable debt management. 

For those shaping fiscal rules, this research provide a path to more effective, adaptable frameworks that meet today’s challenges head-on.

Report details

Topic
Sovereign Debt
Sustainable Development Goals
Sustainable Finance
Impact area
Sustainable Economies
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD, 2025
Report

Canadian Oil and Gas Production in the Global Clean Energy Transition

Outlook and economic risks

This report assesses economic impacts of business-as-usual investment in Canadian oil and gas production. Using investment and production costs data from Rystad Energy, these impacts are modelled under three global demand scenarios from the International Energy Agency. The report finds restricting oil and gas expansion could effectively mitigate economic risks for Canada's investors, industry, and government, especially as the energy transition accelerates.

June 25, 2025

Canada's oil and gas industry is highly exposed to shifting international markets, with 81% of oil and 44% of gas exported abroad. As a result, the profitability of Canadian production is vulnerable to weakening international demand, rising competition, and climate-related trade risks. 

Using three oil and gas demand scenarios from the International Energy Agency and global market modelling by Rystad Energy, this report finds the following:

  • Up to 66% of future capital investments in Canadian oil and gas projects (2025–2040) are at risk of becoming stranded under a 1.5°C climate scenario. The percentage of stranded investments could be even higher in a world where carbon capture and storage technologies underperform.
  • Even under current global policies, 5% of projected investments may fail to deliver economic returns. Under announced climate policies, including existing net-zero pledges, the share of stranded forecasted investments rises to 39%.
  • Economic risks to investors, industry, and governments could be mitigated in all three demand scenarios by restricting future oil and gas development in Canada and abroad. 

It has long been assumed that Canada's best economic interests lie in the continued expansion of oil and gas production. Instead, this analysis suggests a new paradigm whereby the most efficient way to leverage the economic potential of Canada's oil and gas industry is to limit its expansion while using the remaining revenues to accelerate growth in clean industries consistent with a changing global economy.

Participating experts

Report details

Topic
Climate Change Mitigation
Energy
Impact area
Climate
Sustainable Economies
Nature
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD and Environmental Defence, 2025
Report

Tracking Progress on Supporting Workers and Communities in Canada's Energy Transition

Proactive planning is crucial to supporting workers and communities as the world transitions to a net-zero economy and society. This report proposes a set of indicators that will enable Canada to establish a baseline and track progress to support workers and communities through implementation of the 2024 Canadian Sustainable Jobs Act.

June 24, 2025

Key Findings

  • Measuring the risk exposure and transition readiness of communities requires evaluating the economic importance of fossil fuels to a region's economy and the institutional capacity to enable sustainable jobs and worker supports.

  • Response capacity relies on governance structures and processes that foster a whole-of-government approach, ensure corporate transparency and accountability, and bring workers, employers, and Indigenous governments and communities into the conversation.

  • The success of sustainable jobs policies includes not just the number of new jobs created but also the quality of new jobs, equitable access to them, and the availability of training opportunities.

  • Critical outcomes of Canada's Sustainable Jobs Act include growth of low-carbon industries, alignment with national or regional climate objectives, and improved socio-economic well-being of the population.

This set of key indicators—selected based on federal laws, data availability, and government influence—includes 18 quantitative and qualitative measurements. 

Key indicators for tracking progress on sustainable jobs 

Risk and readiness

Economic exposure

  • Community susceptibility: Workforce disruption based on employment in high-emitting industries and transition-vulnerable sectors.
  • Fossil fuel revenue dependence: Percentage of total government revenues derived from fossil fuel-related activities (including direct revenues from fossil fuel taxes and royalties and indirect revenues from income taxes of fossil fuel workers).

Institutional preparedness

  • Social protection coverage: Share of the population covered by employment insurance by equity-deserving group and by sector. 

Response

Governance and processes

  • Governance capacity: Level of resources allocated to a formalized government body (or bodies) responsible for advancing sustainable jobs.
  • Indigenous partnership in governance: Extent of Indigenous partnerships and decision-making authority in the sustainable jobs governance processes, as assessed by Indigenous Peoples.
  • Social dialogue engagement: Number of workers and community members engaged in tripartite social dialogues and stakeholder forums held in the design, monitoring, and implementation of sustainable jobs policies.
  • Private sector regulations: Presence and strength of regulations requiring corporate disclosure and participation related to the transition (e.g., notice of plant closures, number and demographics of affected workers, obligation to fund retraining).
  • Policies managing declining industries: Presence of policies to manage the impacts of declining industries, including the fossil fuel industry, and mandate emissions reductions. 

Results

Net-zero alignment and economic diversification

  • Climate alignment: Extent to which sustainable jobs plans commit to the Paris Agreement and national or regional climate objectives.
  • Relative GDP growth: GDP in low-carbon industries compared to GDP in high-carbon industries and overall GDP.

Employment and decent work

  • Net new sustainable jobs: Number of net new sustainable jobs created by the sector and region per 1,000 jobs.
  • Workforce retraining: Number of workers receiving training to transition into or enter sustainable jobs by equity-deserving group.
  • Displaced worker support: Proportion of displaced workers with access to social security, relocation assistance, and affordable housing.
  • Sustainable job compensation: Annual (median) compensation in sustainable jobs by sector, compared to median compensation across all jobs.
  • Sustainable job retention rate: Proportion of employees in sustainable jobs that retain their jobs for one year or more.
  • Collective agreement coverage: Proportion of workers in sustainable jobs covered by a collective agreement by sector relative to the average across the sector.
  • Employment equity: Employment rate of underrepresented groups (Indigenous Peoples, women and gender-diverse peoples, people with disabilities, Black and other racialized individuals, 2SLGBTQI+, and other equity-seeking groups) in sustainable jobs.

Social equity

  • Income inequality: Distribution of income across a population, indicating the extent of inequality (Gini coefficient). 

These proposed indicators provide a starting point for tracking sustainable jobs, but they should ultimately be refined through a collaborative process with tripartite stakeholders (workers, employers, and government), as well as with affected Indigenous governments and communities.

Report details

Topic
Energy
Just Transition
Impact area
Climate
Sustainable Economies
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD, 2025