Report

Leaving No Canadian Behind

Measuring the well-being of vulnerable Canadians for effective SDG implementation

By committing to the 2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), Canada also pledged to "leave no one behind" in its development efforts. This will only be possible if we improve how we monitor the well-being of the country's most marginalized groups.

May 5, 2021
  • Canada should adopt a multi-tiered #data4SDGs approach where organizations that work with marginalized people gather and govern #data to measure the state of their well-being.

  • Bottom-up implementation of the #SDGs requires bottom-up measurement. Countries like Canada should aim to mobilize disaggregated data on groups that are inherently difficult to measure.

  • Tracking the progress of marginalized groups toward the #SDGs creates new #data needs, including the need to join up data from different sources that developed independently of each other.

While most Canadians enjoy a high standard of living, numerous groups are being left behind in the country. A low income, for example, hampers almost 15% of Canadian households. The groups being left behind are very diverse—and include Indigenous Peoples (First Nations, Métis, and Inuit), recent and elderly immigrants, people with disabilities, lone-parent households, and members of the LGBTQ* community.

The factors that burden these groups are similarly diverse and the challenges for measuring their well-being relate to the empowering them in the data collection process as well as the specific risk factors they face. After all, marginalized groups may have different perceptions, values, and priorities, leading to diverging perceptions of their situation and the measures needed to improve their situation.

Leaving No Canadian Behind uses a combination of literature research, systematic scans, interviews, and data analysis to explore:

  • measurement challenges related to leaving no one behind
  • current international practices
  • what is known about vulnerable populations in Canada
  • available complementary data sources
  • the role of data interoperability

The report shows there are several opportunities to provide space and support for bottom-up community-driven measurement that complements existing indicator frameworks and data—all while putting marginalized groups in charge of how their needs are measured.

Report

Options to Incorporate Circular Economy Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements

This report explores ways in which trade policy can further support a transition to a more circular economy using regional trade agreements (RTAs) as a vehicle. In doing so, it suggests possible options to incorporate circular economy-related provisions in future RTAs, building on precedents with similar objectives in agreements currently in force or under negotiation.

May 3, 2021
  • Some trading blocs have started including circular economy provisions in their RTAs—with the European Union taking the lead—but so far these references remain largely embryonic.

  • Circular economy-related provisions may be integrated into horizontal chapters (e.g., on environment or sustainable development, trade in goods, services, subsidies, investment, or government procurement) by making specific references to circularity.

  • Circular economy objectives can also be reflected in dedicated sectoral chapters or stand-alone annexes or included as specific annexes attached to broader chapters (e.g., technical barriers to trade).

Many countries and economic blocs are beginning to embark on transforming their economies into a circular model. This transition entails a deep paradigm shift set to address the triple crises of climate change, nature and biodiversity loss, and the unsustainable use of natural resources. In today’s globally connected economy, international trade will play a critical role in this equation by exploiting comparative advantages and economies of scale. Cross-border exchanges of goods and services related to the circular economy already occur at all stages of the value chain, including upstream services related to circular design, goods for refurbishment and remanufacturing, and trade in waste and secondary materials.

Governments can use a range of trade-related policy measures, including tariff and non-tariff measures, to encourage the transition away from the take–make–waste economic model. Regional trade agreements, among other mechanisms, can be a vehicle for cooperation on the trade and circular economy interface between specific trading partners. The European Union, for example, has a Circular Economy Action Plan, which will require mainstreaming circular economy objectives in its free trade agreements. As a contribution to this emerging debate, this policy brief explores possible options to incorporate circular economy-related provisions in trade agreements based on existing precedents.

Report details

Report

E-commerce Joint Statement Initiative Negotiations Among World Trade Organization Members: State of play and the impacts of COVID-19

This paper provides an update on the e-commerce Joint Statement Initiative negotiations among a group of WTO members, looking at developments from early 2020 onward.

April 29, 2021

The author describes how the negotiations have been affected by the new context of COVID-19 and highlights the pandemic’s impacts on e-commerce, economic development, and gender equality and social inclusion (GESI) aspects. Finally, the author gives an overview of the negotiations’ key issues where there are indications of convergence, and others where divergence remains, as the group prepares for the WTO’s Twelfth Ministerial Conference (MC12).

The author acknowledges substantive research support from Monica Werimo and Emmeline Perreve. This brief also benefitted from the review of Rashid S. Kaukab, Executive Director of CUTS International, Geneva and Sofia Baliño, Communications and Editorial Manager for IISD’s Economic Law and Policy program.

This material has been produced with funding by UK aid from the UK Government. The Umbrella Grant is a project of the Trade and Investment Advocacy Fund (TAF2+) and is implemented by the International Institute for Sustainable Development, in consortium with CUTS International Geneva and BKP Economic Advisors.

Views expressed in the publication are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect HM Government’s official positions or those of the Trade and Investment Advocacy Fund (TAF2+).

CUTS International Geneva

Report details

Topic
Trade
Project
Digital Trade
Impact area
Sustainable Economies
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD and CUTS International, 2021
Report

Micro, Small, and Medium-Sized Enterprises: Key developments and update in the Informal Working Group discussions among World Trade Organization members

This report provides an update on the Informal Working Group on MSMEs' work for June–December 2020, including COVID-19's impact on MSMEs, especially those led or owned by women.

April 29, 2021

This report builds on an earlier brief covering the Informal Working Group (IWG) on Micro, Small, and Medium-Sized Enterprises' (MSMEs) work since its inception and incorporates some of the key considerations involving gender equality and social inclusion. The authors note the policy responses at the national, regional, and international levels to help MSMEs affected by the pandemic. Lastly, the brief summarizes some of the immediate next steps for the IWG, particularly in the lead-up to the World Trade Organization's (WTO) Twelfth Ministerial Conference.

This material has been produced with funding by UK aid from the UK Government. The Umbrella Grant is a project of the Trade and Investment Advocacy Fund (TAF2+) and is implemented by the International Institute for Sustainable Development, in consortium with CUTS International Geneva and BKP Economic Advisors.

The report benefitted from Rhea Pradeep and Chidochashe Ncube’s research inputs and was substantively reviewed by Sofia Baliño and Rashid S. Kaukab.

Views expressed in the publication are the authors’ own and do not necessarily reflect HM Government’s official positions or those of TAF2+.

CUTS International Geneva

Report details

Topic
Sustainable Development Goals
Trade
Impact area
Sustainable Economies
Publisher
IISD
Copyright
IISD and CUTS International, 2021
Report

Review: Health in National Adaptation Plans (NAPs)

Climate change has a significant effect on health, whether through heat stress, increased spread of vector-borne diseases, or harm due to extreme weather events. 

April 21, 2021

The National Adaptation Plan (NAP) process helps countries address the impacts of climate change on their economies, communities, and ecosystems. This includes efforts to promote adaptation in the health sector.

Developed in collaboration with the World Health Organization (WHO), this report analyzes how health impacts are addressed in 19 NAP documents submitted to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) as of December 2020. Furthermore, it identifies areas of opportunity for greater consideration of health in NAP processes, toward climate-resilient health systems.

Report details

Topic
Climate Change Adaptation
Region
Global
Project
NAP Global Network
Impact area
Climate
Publisher
World Health Organization (WHO)
Copyright
World Health Organization (WHO), 2021
Report

The Joint Initiative on Investment Facilitation: Developments from 2020 and the road ahead to MC12

This stocktaking brief provides an update on the structured discussions on investment facilitation among a group of World Trade Organization (WTO) members and subsequent negotiations, focusing on those developments that have taken place since the release of the streamlined text in early 2020.

April 27, 2021

Along with the procedural steps and transitions that have taken place in the investment facilitation talks over the past year, the authors refer to the wider context of COVID-19 and what the pandemic has meant for investment flows and governance processes. They provide an overview of the latest available version of the investment facilitation texts, including the informal consolidated text and revised draft text, as of February 2021, and outline where the talks are expected to go next.

This material has been produced with funding by UK aid from the UK Government. The Umbrella Grant is a project of the Trade and Investment Advocacy Fund (TAF2+) and is implemented by the International Institute for Sustainable Development, in consortium with CUTS International, Geneva and BKP Economic Advisors.

Views expressed in the publication are the authors’ own and do not necessarily reflect HM Government’s official positions or those of TAF2+.

CUTS International Geneva

Report details

Report

How to Target LPG Subsidies in India: Step 2. Evaluating policy options in Jharkhand

May 20, 2021
  • The poorest 40% of households in rural and urban parts of Jharkhand received less than 30% of government LPG support in 2018/19 when LPG subsidies comprised nearly 28% of India’s energy subsidies.

  • Poor households in India may benefit 2 times less than better-off consumers from LPG support if the government doesn’t change the LPG subsidy policy design.

  • The majority of India’s rural households continue to use more of the freely available wood and biomass-based fuels instead of subsidized LPG, while better-off households with higher consumption of subsidized LPG end up receiving a larger share of the subsidies.

Based on a survey of over 900 households in Jharkhand, this report finds that LPG subsidies are not well targeted and that poor households in Jharkhand can receive 2 times less in LPG subsidies than better-off consumers. The poorest 40% of households in rural and urban parts of Jharkhand received less than 30% of government LPG support in 2018/19 when LPG subsidies comprised nearly 28% of all Central Government energy subsidies.

Since May 2020, LPG subsidies per cylinder have been effectively removed. At the same time, the COVID-19 crisis has severely affected incomes, further stressing the need to provide support for affordable clean cooking for the most vulnerable.

The research analyzed strategies to improve LPG subsidy targeting but did not identify a “magic bullet” for easily improving LPG subsidy distribution among poor households. The main bottleneck in improving subsidy distribution appears to be the low consumption of subsidized LPG cylinders among poor households and the high consumption among better-off households. Until reasons for low consumption by poor households are better understood and addressed and an effective way is found to restrict benefits for better-off consumers, policy-makers can consider applying volumetric targeting to continue to limit overall subsidy expenditure.

Since the COVID-19 crisis began, many households in India have seen a dramatic fall in incomes and are anticipated to fall back into poverty. Coupled with Jharkhand’s existing high levels of poverty, this strongly suggests that the choice of any new targeting mechanism when LPG subsidies are reintroduced must be undertaken with care to not increase the hardships for any poor households.

The report recommends making energy access fairer for poor households by encouraging the Central and state governments to analyze who benefits most from LPG subsidies and test different strategies to improve targeting when they are reintroduced.

Report details

Report

Sustainable Asset Valuation (SAVi) of Stormwater Infrastructure Solutions in Johannesburg, South Africa

April 20, 2021
  • Over the life cycle of the infrastructure, the hybrid solution and the full renaturalization of the stream are the most cost-effective investments. Grey stormwater infrastructure requires the highest upfront investment, while annual operations and maintenance costs are higher for the renaturalized stream.

  • The hybrid solution and renaturalized stream provide additional benefits, some of which the grey stormwater infrastructure, by design, cannot provide. Among these benefits are improved flood mitigation resulting in avoided costs of flood damages, additional employment from landscaping, and environmental benefits such as carbon sequestration and additional water supply. The avoided cost of flood damages is by far the largest additional benefit of the nature-based stormwater infrastructure.

  • Under different climate change scenarios, the case for nature-based infrastructure options becomes even clearer: the more volatile precipitation patterns become, the larger the benefits in comparison with a grey built solution. Indeed, a grey stormwater solution's capacity is limited by design and therefore less equipped to deal with extreme weather events. This also illustrates the importance of using climate parameters when assessing the costs and benefits of different infrastructure options.

The Paterson Park Precinct project is part of Johannesburg's Corridors of Freedom Initiative, which seeks to improve social cohesion within the urban environment while maximizing environmental and economic benefits. The project is also part of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) Sustainable Cities Impact Program, which promotes holistic urban planning to maximize environmental and social benefits and avoid negative trade-offs. One of the components of the project included an upgrade of the stormwater infrastructure in the precinct area through a combination of grey and green infrastructure. This assessment aims to contribute to that discussion, particularly in light of the city's 2021 Climate Action Plan.

Participating experts

Report details

Report

Sustainable Asset Valuation (SAVi) of Paterson Park's Building Infrastructure: City of Johannesburg (South Africa)

April 20, 2021
  • Over the life cycle of buildings, there are significant cost savings in energy and maintenance expenditures for green buildings.

  • Climate change has the largest impact on the cost of energy expenditures, under both Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios. It also increases the cost of greenhouse gas emissions further under both climate scenarios. This is the case in both the business-as-usual and green building scenarios.

  • Solar power generates a positive return on investment and is a worthwhile investment for buildings in South Africa, especially when taking into account rising electricity prices.

The Paterson Park Precinct project is part of Johannesburg's Corridors of Freedom Initiative, which seeks to improve social cohesion within the urban environment. Buildings (including social housing, sports facilities, and a recreational centre) are a core component of this project. The project is also part of the Global Environment Facility (GEF) Sustainable Cities Impact Program, which promotes holistic urban planning to maximize environmental and social benefits and avoid negative trade-offs. The Sustainable Asset Valuation (SAVi) application includes an economic and financial valuation of the Paterson Park Project – Buildings, a comparative economic and financial valuation of a building with higher energy and water efficiency requirements and a simulation of these values under different climate scenarios. The Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) data that was used for this assessment includes precipitation patterns, temperature changes, and heating and cooling degree days.

Report details

Report

Sustainable Asset Valuation (SAVi) of Agroforestry Nature-Based Infrastructure in Welkenraedt (Belgium)

April 20, 2021
  • The net benefits of the agroforestry project are estimated at EUR 3.9 million over a 20-year lifetime period for an investment cost of EUR 607,629. This is due to positive externalities, avoided costs, and additional potential revenue streams, such as, for example, fodder and wood pellet production.

  • Due to climate change, these benefits will only increase further and make agroforestry projects even more economically attractive. For example, agroforestry has a cooling effect that reduces heat stress on livestock, improving milk production and thus farmers' revenues.

This report describes the Sustainable Asset Valuation (SAVi) assessment of an agroforestry project in the municipality of Welkenraedt, Belgium. Agroforestry is nature-based infrastructure (NBI) that aims to maintain and restore soil productivity, combat erosion, maintain high water quality, and strengthen climate resilience in the area. Agroforestry is included in the municipality’s climate plans.