Is India Ready for an Electric Vehicle Revolution?
This article was originally published in IISD's Trade and Sustainability Review, Volume 1, Issue 3.
Electric vehicles (EVs) are revolutionizing the world of road transport. The global EV market grew 43% annually on average over the last five years, and the worldwide automobile market penetration rate of EVs stood at about 2.6% in 2019.
This is expected to explode during the coming decade.
Many COVID-19 recovery packages in countries including China, Germany, France, and Canada, as well as the newly proposed plan in the United States, focus heavily on EVs. Deloitte predicts that annual new sales of EVs will top USD 30 million by 2030.
To date, India lags behind other key markets such as China, Europe, and the United States. The global EV stock reached 7.2 million units in 2019, of which 47% were in China, 25% in Europe and 21% in the United States. The rest of the world accounted for only 600,000 units, with just 170,000 sold in India.
But EVs are of great interest in India. The electrification of road transport serves multiple purposes. It is a green industrial policy that supports a post-pandemic economic recovery. It is intended to reduce oil imports and strengthen energy security. And it is central to reducing air pollution and mitigating climate change. It is a central component of net-zero ambitions worldwide and an important carbon emission reduction measure, second only to greening power sectors.
“Almost 97.5% of all electric vehicles sold in India were two-wheelers, indicating an especially strong market in the two- and three-wheeler segment.”
Those objectives feature strongly in India’s push to electrify transport.
While less than 0.5% of Indian car sales in 2019 were EVs, the level of stock here is not the right indicator by which to judge the country’s readiness or interest. India sold 69,000 units in 2017–2018 and about 143,000 units in 2018–2019. This indicates a strong growth rate that is likely to accelerate in the next years. Almost 97.5% of all electric vehicles sold in India were two-wheelers, indicating an especially strong market in the two- and three-wheeler segment.
The national government and state governments have adopted several encouraging policies since the start of the pandemic. Nationally, for example, the government has incentivized the deployment of e-buses and charging stations. On the state level, Telangana has exempted the first 200,000 two-wheeler EVs from road tax and registration fees, while Gujarat will offer government subsidies for students purchasing two-wheeler EVs, and rickshaw drivers and self-employed people buying three-wheeler EVs. In 2020, Delhi also launched a progressive EV policy including purchase incentives based on battery range and category.
These measures are promising, but need more streamlining and coordination between policies from the central government, state governments, and local (city) governments.
Suitable Policy Framework and Incentives Are Needed
To truly improve EV adoption and India’s role as a value chain participant, the government cannot rely solely on subsidies; it will also need to attract more private investment to the country. The good news is that there are positive signs of investor interest. Just last year, Tesla announced the opening of a factory in Karnataka in southwest India, and venture capitalists are expected to invest more than USD 300 million in EV companies across the country.
This, however, pales in comparison to global investment in EVs.
Of known automaker investment plans before the pandemic, at least USD 300 billion was earmarked for EV investment in the next 5 to 10 years. More than 45% of that budget was intended for operations in China, with most of the remainder divided among Germany, the United States, South Korea, Japan, and France. To become a major EV investment destination, India must create the right policy framework and incentives.
It has started doing so with the government’s Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Electric Vehicles scheme, or FAME. The program, launched in 2015, aimed both to promote EV adoption and to incentivize manufacturers to build EVs in India. In the first phase of FAME, the government provided USD 130 million in subsidies to support the purchase of electric two-wheelers and three-wheelers and hybrid and electric cars and buses. The first phase was generally considered a success as far as sales are concerned.
FAME’s second phase was a considerable upgrade to USD 1.4 billion of EV subsidies, of which about 85% was earmarked for purchasing subsidies and 10% to charging infrastructure. It started in 2019 and was intended to run until 2022.
A core component of this phase was again to accelerate local manufacturing. Two years in, however, the results are not what had been anticipated. By early 2021, only about 10% of the EV deployment target for Phase 2 had been reached.
“To truly improve EV adoption and India’s role as a value chain participant, the government cannot rely solely on subsidies; it will also need to attract more private investment to the country.”
The Society of Manufacturers of Electric Vehicles said this was because of a slower evolution of the domestic component manufacturing market and regulatory requirements for fiscal incentives that keep EV costs too high. Additionally, an uncertain medium-term regulatory environment and the lack of affordable finance continue to deter private investment.
As a result, the Indian EV revolution is not yet at cruising speed, and policy priorities were moved to deployment and investment ahead of local manufacturing requirements. The government also launched a production-linked incentive scheme to encourage companies to start manufacturing EV batteries locally.
An updated analysis of investor, trade, and skill gap barriers is needed to tweak the regulatory environment in a way that facilitates such deployment and value chain investment. This process could also be the perfect moment to kickstart policy coordination and design related to end-of-life EVs, particularly with regard to urban mining and EV battery repurposing and recycling.
India Can Play a Key Role in EV Battery Recycling
In terms of end-of-life EVs, India is also not yet prepared. In all fairness, few major players are.
About 70% of hazardous waste in global landfills comes from e-waste. Just 94,000 metric tons of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) were recycled globally in 2019, most of them from portable consumer electronics. In the next decade, however, EV batteries will start flooding the end-of-life battery market. The World Economic Forum forecasts that for half of those EV batteries to be recycled by 2030, recycling capacity would need to grow by a factor of 25.
Currently, however, the EV battery recycling industry suffers on different levels, from profitability linked to relatively cheap primary raw material costs, to changing chemical compositions of EV batteries and inefficiencies in the recycling process. While China has specific guidelines on removing, discharging, disassembling, and storing used EV lithium-ion batteries, the other major players—i.e., the United States, Europe, and Japan—still struggle with a regulatory framework that would facilitate profitable recycling.
“With the right incentives and policy framework, India can leapfrog some EV battery recycling barriers and become a major player within the next decade.”
Reassuringly, the number of patents in EV battery recycling has increased dramatically in the last 10 years, showing the potential for innovation.
With the right incentives and policy framework, India can leapfrog some EV battery recycling barriers and become a major player within the next decade. The potential is huge, with a global market expected to surge to 705,000 end-of-life LIBs by 2025 and to 9 million by 2040—most of which will be EV LIBs.
Like China, India has a major EV growth market and would thus be able to count on a reliable supply of end-of-life batteries in the future. Unlike China, India does not have global supply chains for primary materials such as lithium and cobalt, and so urban mining and recycling are also needed for India to become a large-scale EV battery manufacturer.
The first stages of EV LIB recycling are also barely automated and thus require a lot of manual labour. Here, too, India could have a comparative advantage compared to other major players since it has a large population and lower labour costs compared to Western countries.
India’s Government Has Its Work Cut Out
The success of circular economy policies is not guaranteed, however. It took China a decade of regulatory development to become the market leader in LIB recycling.
India’s government has work to do—from improving regulations related to battery collection, transport, and storage, to coordinating training programs to handle batteries; from crafting labelling and traceability requirements to clarifying contractual and ownership models; and from improving extended producer responsibility to facilitating clustering and joint ventures that can drive efficiencies and cost reductions.
It is clear that EVs are set to transform global road transport, and India will be a colossal market for deployment. It is both logical and necessary that India also seek to become a manufacturing hub that can contribute to both EV value chains and battery recycling.
To do so, however, the government needs to analyze barriers and adjust its regulatory and institutional frameworks to accommodate those barriers and attract private investment on a larger scale.
Tom Moerenhout is a Senior Associate with IISD’s Global Subsidies Initiative.
You might also be interested in
Glasgow summit pledge to phase out fossil fuel subsidies faces an uphill battle
Subsidies that make coal, oil and gas cheaper are widely recognized as a roadblock to a transition toward cleaner energy. But they’ve proven hard to get rid of.
How natural gas could thwart or support India's renewables progress
As India builds more supply infrastructure and power generation capacity for natural gas, experts say its use must be limited to that of a 'transition fuel' from coal to renewable energy.
What's at stake for India and South Asia at COP26?
South Asia is home to nearly a quarter of the world’s population, and to some of the countries most vulnerable to the impacts of climate change.
The pandemic as premonition
The loss to the Indian economy due to the pandemic shutdown, and the loss of jobs, shows that the current model of growth is unsustainable, even loss-making, for India.