India's Energy Transition: Subsidies for gasoline, diesel and electric vehicles
- A fuel price cut by India’s central government from October 2018 to June 2019 resulted in subsidies of INR 26,957 crore (USD 3.9 billion) for gasoline and diesel.
- This far overshadowed funding for the government’s flagship electric vehicles (EV) subsidy program of INR 10,000 crore (USD 1.4 billion) over three years.
- The funds would have been better spent supporting India’s transition to EVs and renewable energy, given that together these technologies will reduce air pollution.
This brief examines how the latest support by the Government of India for electric vehicles (EVs) compares with subsidies for conventional vehicles and their main fuels, gasoline and diesel. Analysis is centred on two major policy developments.
First, when faced with rising world oil prices in October 2018, the Central Government reduced the excise tax on fuel by INR 1.5 (USD 0.02) per litre and required state-owned oil marketing companies (OMCs) to reduce their margin by INR 1 (USD 0.01). This decision was partially reversed in the 2019-2020 Union Budget.
Second, the government announced phase two of its flagship EV subsidy program, the Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Hybrid and Electric Vehicles (FAME) scheme, or FAME II.
The rising trend for EV subsidies in India has been strengthened by the addition of INR 10,000 crore (USD 1.4 billion) for FAME II over three years. However, subsidies for oil, gasoline and diesel, which had been declining since FY 2014, have also seen a sharp increase: cuts to excise and OMC margins resulted in foregone revenue and market price support of INR 26,957 crore (USD 3.9 billion) from October 2018 to June 2019.
If improving air quality is indeed a high priority of the Central Government, as it states, the funds would have been better spent supporting India’s transition to EVs and renewable energy rather than sheltering petroleum-reliant technology from the volatile international oil market.
You might also be interested in
Electricity overcharging: Cross-subsidies cost businesses Rs 75k crore in FY19
Since the National Tariff Policy 2016 prescribed the tolerable extents of cross-subsidy among various segments of electricity consumers, the market-distorting system hasn’t seen a smidgen of correction.
Electricity subsidies increased 32% since FY 2016: Report
New Delhi: Direct tariff electricity subsidies from the state governments have increased 32 per cent since FY 2016, amounting to Rs 1,10,391 crore ($14.96 billion) in FY 2019.
Soaring power subsidies reflect discom weakness
The precarious state of India’s power distribution companies can be seen in the sharp rise in state government subsidies to such companies over the past few years, even as sales and profitability have dipped.
View: With India transitioning towards renewables, it's time for PSUs to catch up
PSUs can't just turn into Public Spending Units that try to buy their way out of this crisis. They must look at the bigger picture, and become Public Sustainability Units.