South Africa’s Energy Subsidies Tripled Since 2017, Hitting ZAR 172 Billion in 2020—New Report
The government must align its energy fiscal policies with South Africa’s climate and environmental goals.
January 31, 2022—Energy subsidies in South Africa more than tripled between FY2017 and FY2020 to ZAR 172 billion (USD 10.4 billion), with the highest subsidies allocated to fossil fuels, including coal-fired electricity, according to a new report from the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) released today.
The government spent nearly ZAR 67 billion on bailouts for carbon-intensive companies, particularly the state-owned utility Eskom, as well as ZAR 43 billion to support the oil and gas industry, found the report, titled South Africa’s Energy Fiscal Policies: An inventory of subsidies, taxes and policies impacting the energy transition. In addition, carbon tax exemptions cost South Africa a further ZAR 45 billion in lost tax revenues.
In total, the data shows that energy subsidies more than tripled from the ZAR 58 billion allocated in FY2017. At ZAR 172 billion, the government’s expenditure on energy subsidies in 2020 exceeds the country’s annual spending on police services and defense & state security, combined.
“Fiscal policies—subsidies, taxes, and grants—are key tools that governments can use to reach their energy and climate targets, but right now in South Africa, billions are spent propping up the existing fossil fuel system,” says IISD’s Chido Muzondo, co-author of the report. “These subsidies represent an enormous cost to the public budget and take a heavy toll on people’s health and the climate.”
IISD experts found that pollution from fossil fuel use costs South Africans ZAR 550 billion each year in environmental harm and damage to public health.
The study, which explores the extent to which South Africa’s current energy fiscal policies reflect its goal to develop a robust, low-carbon, and affordable domestic energy system, highlights that current policies are not in line with the country’s energy targets and environmental imperatives. The report’s authors provide concrete recommendations for the government to realign its fiscal policies by reforming fossil fuels subsidies and increasing investments in clean energy.
To stop the trend of rising subsidies, the government must tie bailouts to the energy transition and phase out carbon tax exemptions, particularly in the electricity sector, IISD experts recommend.
South Africa should also raise fossil fuel taxes, according to the report, and—to keep pace with growing power demand—boost investments in renewable energy, and explore alternative business models for large-scale renewables.
“On top of discouraging consumption, revenue generated by increasing fossil fuel taxes can be invested in the energy transition in ways that stimulate jobs, economic growth, and fund a just transition for coal workers and communities,” says study co-author Richard Bridle of IISD. “It can also be used to provide targeted support for vulnerable households.”
IISD experts also urge South Africa to improve transparency on energy fiscal policies to send a strong signal to market players and spur the advancement of the clean energy transition.
Chido Muzondo, Policy Advisor, IISD: [email protected]
Richard Bridle, Senior Policy Advisor, IISD: [email protected]
The International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) is an award-winning independent think tank working to accelerate solutions for a stable climate, sustainable resource management, and fair economies. Our work inspires better decisions and sparks meaningful action to help people and the planet thrive. We shine a light on what can be achieved when governments, businesses, non-profits, and communities come together. IISD’s staff of more than 120 people, plus over 150 associates and consultants, come from across the globe and from many disciplines. With offices in Winnipeg, Geneva, Ottawa, and Toronto, our work affects lives in nearly 100 countries.
You might also be interested in
COP27 diary (November 16): '$100 billion in climate finance more of gesture from rich countries'
The 27th Conference of Parties (COP27) to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt, began November 7, 2022. Here’s a look at what happened on day 10 of COP27 climate talks. The draft text for a cover decision is yet to be produced by the COP27 Presidency as of 7.30 am November 17, leading many to wonder how long discussions will continue to arrive at a consensus on the document once released. Just two days of the summit remain.
Governments are subsidizing the destruction of nature even as they promise to protect it
When dignitaries from 196 countries converge in Montreal next week to rub shoulders and hash out a new global agreement to save nature, money will be on the agenda.
Background Note on Fossil Fuel Subsidy Reform
As fossil fuel subsidies are expected to swell following rapidly rising energy prices, IISD offers a background note on the rationale and international initiatives for reforming fossil fuel subsidies.
Switching Fossil Fuel Subsidies in Indonesia to Support a Green Recovery
This brief looks at how Indonesia can start actively promoting renewable energy by removing the existing hurdles to its deployment—such as unattractive renewable energy feed-in tariffs and land and infrastructures barriers—and switching public support from fossil fuels to renewables to meet the country’s clean energy targets.