India's Energy Subsidies Moving in the Right Direction
But do the facts back up the rhetoric? Is the central government walking the talk?
Money, as they say, isn't everything, but an analysis of expenditure patterns reveals a lot about government priorities. And government subsidies affect energy prices, which drive investment and consumption decisions.
A recent study of India's energy subsidies sheds light on exactly which energy types the government is backing. And it's no small amount—INR 151,484 crore (USD 23 billion) in the 2017–19 fiscal years (FYs). The report is an update of a comprehensive inventory released last year.
Consistent with the government's position has been its shift away from subsidizing fossil fuel and toward renewable energy. FY 21016/17 saw a record increase in support for renewable energy of INR 5,766 crore (USD 0.8 billion). At the same time, government support for coal, oil and gas fell by INR 13,418 crore and by INR 120,687 crore from 2014 to 2015, reflecting reform in consumer price subsidies for fuels such as petrol and diesel.
But this is not the full story. Subsidies for fossil fuels were still over three times those for renewables in FY 2017/18 at INR 52,982 crore. Coal alone received more than renewables at INR 15,992 crore and even increased by INR 1,148 crore.
Subsidies for coal can undermine the development of renewables by artificially reducing prices for coal-fired power, the renewables' main competitor. This contributes to air pollution and carbon emissions. Even where there are environmental standards for coal, they aren't always well enforced. One such example is non-compliance with coal washing laws, delivering a benefit of INR 980 crore in FY 2017/18 to coal companies—and incentivizing dirtier air for everyone.
Some energy subsidies are important to achieving certain policy objectives, such as access to energy. Around 70 per cent of India's energy subsidies aim to keep prices low for consumers or to connect households with modern energy, such as the Ujjwala program for cooking gas or the Saubhagya program for electricity.
The single largest support measure in FY 2017/18, accounting for almost half of all energy subsidies, was transfers to electricity companies to keep power prices low (INR 74,925).
Programs to improve access to clean, modern energy are vital for health and improving development outcomes across many areas, as recognized in the UN Sustainable Development Goals. But this does not mean that such programs should be exempt from review? On the contrary, evaluation is essential to ensuring they are effective and delivering value for money.
At the moment, most of India's spending on energy consumption, particularly electricity, is poorly targeted, with many benefits being captured by higher-income households. Efforts have been made to improve targeting, but given their high remaining costs, renewed efforts to direct support to the poor are critical.
Looking at expenditure patterns, alternative ways of providing access to modern energy can also be considered. Kerosene, for example, is still used as the primary source of lighting for 30 per cent of households in some states and by many more as a backup during power outages. Subsidizing kerosene might seem like a lifeline to these households. But kerosene causes indoor air pollution and poses a fire risk, as well as providing low-quality light. Renewable alternatives such as solar lanterns or home systems are available for comparable costs to kerosene over time, but subsidies are needed to help poor households meet the initial upfront costs.
Further support may also be warranted for electric vehicles (EVs), which can help reduce pollution and de-link India's economy from volatile international oil prices. At the moment, when oil prices rise, the subsidy bill increases at the same time that revenues decline due to a variable fuel tax on petrol and diesel. Subsidies for EVs are only in their early stages in India, totalling INR 148 crore in FY 2017/18 and rising to INR 250 crore in FY 2018/19.
Looking forward, the central government's support for renewable electricity is likely to head in the opposite direction to EVs in coming years. Reforms associated with the Goods and Services Tax (GST) will see tax breaks for coal and renewables both decline by about INR 2,000 crore in FY 2018/19, but total tax breaks for coal will still be five times those for renewables. In addition, the largest subsidy for renewables, "viability gap funding," is likely to decline in line with increasingly competitive pricing for renewables.
Despite the increasing competitiveness of utility-scale solar and wind projects, certain clean technologies may continue to require budgetary support. They include offshore wind, energy storage and off-grid solutions. In addition, support for integration costs (such as energy storage) is likely to be needed to accelerate greater uptake of renewables. One potential source of funding is to shift savings from fossil fuel subsidy reform or better subsidy targeting.
Hard data, such as that in this review, provides a welcome anchor point in a debate that is frequently shrouded in spin by governments, interest groups and commentators. Greater transparency and reporting are needed to get the full picture.
Financial information is sorely lacking for many government energy policies, particularly at the state level. Only with full accounting and disclosure can there be the necessary evaluation of energy policies to ensure they are meeting their objectives and delivering value.
You might also be interested in
How Jharkhand's rich households corner power subsidies worth Rs 300 cr
Jharkhand's electricity consumers received a total subsidy worth Rs 1,250 crore ($170 million) during April 2018-March 2019 (or financial year 2018-19).
India mulls closing dirtiest coal plants: Why the nation's coal fleet is in dire need of transformation
According to latest reports, India's power ministry is considering a proposal that may see the closure of some of the nation's dirtiest coal plants as policymakers seek to address the climate crisis.
OPINION: Can India afford a green stimulus during the pandemic?
A deeper look at fossil fuel subsidies and renewable energy solutions suggests that green stimulus could be India’s most economically viable path to recovery.
Part 2 – How Can India’s Energy Sector Recover Sustainably from COVID-19?
From IISD and CEEW, Part 2 of a three-part commentary series takes a deep dive into how India’s energy sector is coping with the impacts of COVID-19 and what this means for the sustainable energy transition.