Lack of competition with new GBP 600 million public procurement deal between the U.K. and Amazon may cost taxpayers
Recently, the Yorkshire Purchasing Organization (YPO) awarded a five-year contract of GBP 600 million to Amazon for the supply of an online one-stop shop for all public agencies in Yorkshire.
This digital marketplace from the retail powerhouse will provide everything from paper to medical supplies for Yorkshire’s education, social and emergency services. These vital public services will be able to purchase everything they need in one place, as opposed to the region’s previously complicated procurement system involving multiple suppliers.
YPO is thinking big about public procurement. Gillian Askew, YPO’s Head of Procurement, has said “good procurement… can be nothing short of transformational,” and I could not agree more. The news of a major purchasing body taking an innovative leap is cause for excitement.
An online one-stop shop is a great opportunity for sustainable procurement, something that typically requires a certain scale. For example, suppliers will sell and produce their goods in environmentally friendly ways if they know there is a demand. In the case of Amazon’s new digital marketplace for Yorkshire, that demand coalesces on the items every public agency in the region purchases. This is known as “bundling demand” and is one strategy for implementing sustainable public procurement, which is exactly what Amazon’s one-stop shop can do.
I deliberately say “can” because it only accomplishes this goal if we ask for environmental or social sustainability standards to be included. We do not know if any such aspects will be considered when Amazon sets up their marketplace, as the tender documents do not mention sustainability.
This missed sustainability opportunity could be remedied throughout the negotiation process. Another concern remains, however: Amazon was the only company to submit a valid expression of interest for the one-stop shop project for the Yorkshire community. Good public procurement is based on open and fair competition because only then can the best available solution be identified and selected.
YPO is moving forward against best practices by only considering Amazon’s bid, ignoring how open and fair competition is a core principle of public procurement. The fact that YPO complied with the procurement rules is no justification for circumventing this crucial principle. Competition in public procurement is essential to identifying innovative solutions that bring value for taxpayers.
It is a jump in the right direction when purchasing bodies experiment with innovative ways to transform public procurement. But awarding a GBP 600 million contract to a multinational company with no specifications on sustainability, and without considering another service provider, means this leap could fall flat on its face. Yorkshire’s communities deserve a better attempt at getting value for money for their taxes.
You might also be interested in
Public Procurement in Canada’s Trade Agreements
Imagine this: A municipality pledges to make all of its buildings carbon-neutral by 2050.
Low-Carbon Innovation for Sustainable Infrastructure: The role of public procurement
This report discusses how to leverage the power of public procurement laws, policies and practices to drive low-carbon innovation in the construction and infrastructure sectors.
Leveraging the Power of the Public Purse: Using public procurement of low-carbon innovation for sustainable infrastructure recommendations to the European Commission and EU member states
i24c and International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) publish recommendations for the European Commission and member state authorities on how to better leverage the power of the public purse to drive demand of low-carbon innovation in sustainable infrastructure.
Guidebook on the Management and Financing of Soil Rehabilitation Projects in China
Drawing on best practices worldwide in funding environmental rehabilitation, this guidebook explores innovative design and the use of financial mechanisms to finance and manage soil remediation projects.