IISD Responds to European Commission’s Proposed International Investment Court
GENEVA—May 6, 2015—The International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) welcomes efforts taken by the European Commission to address serious weaknesses in the global governance of foreign investment, announced this week by European Commissioner for Trade, Cecilia Malmström. However, IISD cautions against including a special mechanism to settle disputes between foreign investors and governments in the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP)—even with the innovations proposed by the Commission. There are no compelling arguments for the inclusion of such a mechanism in a treaty between parties with established democracies and independent court systems.
In preparations for talks with the European Parliament and European Council today and Thursday, Ms. Malmström has released a new set of ideas on improvements to the way disputes between foreign investors and states are settled under the TTIP.
The prevailing system of dispute settlement in investment agreements, commonly referred to as investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), has been subject to wide-spread criticism by civil society groups and parliamentarians, as well as some EU member states. IISD has for many years exposed the problems with ISDS and promoted practical solutions.
“Ms. Malmström has rightly focused on the arbitration system as a key source of concern,” said Nathalie Bernasconi, group director of IISD’s Economic Law and Policy Program. “But that discussion is mostly relevant for the 1200 treaties that EU member states have signed in the past and that need to be renegotiated and replaced. There is no urgency to reform the arbitration system in TTIP; it should simply be left out of the agreement. The European Union and United States have courts that are perfectly capable of handling these disputes in a way that is fair and transparent.”
Among Ms. Malmström’s proposals are that all arbitrators are selected from a roster of competent professionals chosen by the state parties to the investment agreement. Those arbitrators would need to be “independent” and “impartial,” although what that means in practice is not spelled out.
The creation of such a roster moves ISDS procedures closer to a permanent court, which Ms. Malmström says should be the EU’s ultimate objective.
“The creation of a permanent court to settle investment disputes requires serious consideration,” said Ms. Bernasconi. “However, multilateral solutions require multilateral approaches. We look forward to knowing more about Mss Malmström’s ideas on a possible multilateral architecture, which hopefully includes thoughtful options for mediation and broad stakeholder participation when necessary.”
For more information please contact Sumeep Bath at [email protected] or +1 (204) 958 7740 (in Canada) or Damon Vis-Dunbar at [email protected] or +41 22 917-8848 (in Switzerland).
About IISD
The International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) is a globally recognized think tank with 3 decades of experience working to solve the world’s most pressing sustainable development challenges. We combine deep expertise in a wide range of issues with a collaborative approach to research, policy advice, and hands-on support to ensure these solutions are brought to life. Headquartered in Winnipeg, Manitoba, we are a diverse team of over 300 professionals working from offices in Canada, Switzerland, and other locations around the world.
You might also be interested in
Midpoint of the UN Tax Convention Negotiations: Where do talks stand?
The negotiations for a new UN Framework Convention on International Tax Cooperation have hit their halfway point. Here's a look at where things stand, what was on the table this round, and what's coming next.
Canadian Exporters Face New Reporting Costs as Carbon Border Taxes Multiply
The European Union’s carbon border tax will add new compliance costs for Canadian businesses that trade certain products, especially steel and aluminum, to the bloc. The increased costs—linked to differing demands for measuring, reporting, and verifying a product’s greenhouse gas emissions across the growing number of countries adopting border carbon adjustment (BCA) mechanisms—“make it tough for any exporter to those markets,” Aaron Cosbey, senior associate at the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD), told The Energy Mix.
Experimental Lakes gets $2M for major facilities upgrade
A one-of-a-kind research station is studying small lakes to inform freshwater science all over the world is getting a new facility with more space for scientists and students. Located between Dryden and Kenora, the International Institute for Sustainable Development’s Experimental Lakes Area allows scientists and students to run experiments on 58 small lakes in the area.
Province investing $2M to ‘ensure northwestern Ontario remains a global leader in freshwater science and research’
The Government of Ontario is making a targeted investment to “strengthen northern Ontario's leadership in freshwater science, support research and innovation and create new educational and economic opportunities in the region.” On Aug. 13, the Northern Ontario Heritage Fund Corporation (NOHFC) — a regional granting subsidiary of the provincial government — announced that it will be investing $2 million to build a new Centre for Climate and Lake Learning at the International Institute for Sustainable Development Experimental Lakes Area (IISD-ELA), which is located about halfway between Kenora and Dryden.