What Is the Energy Charter Treaty and What Does it Mean for Sustainable Development?
What Is the Energy Charter Treaty?
The Energy Charter Treaty, commonly referred to as the ECT, is an investment treaty that was developed in the 1990s to enable multilateral cooperation in the energy sector in the wake of the Cold War. Its 53 contracting parties include countries in Europe, Asia, and the Middle East, as well as the European Union and Euratom.
However, the treaty is being used more and more frequently by fossil fuel investors to mitigate the losses they incur from public policies. Using a mechanism known as investor–state dispute settlement, or ISDS, the fossil fuel industry has sued governments and obtained record-breaking damages awards that cost taxpayers millions of dollars.
IISD research shows that the fossil fuel industry uses ISDS more than any other sector. The average amount awarded—over USD 600 million—is almost five times the amount awarded in non-fossil fuel cases. The ECT is facilitating such claims more than any other investment treaty.
What Is at Stake?
Arbitration claims challenging government actions made in the public interest, such as environmental policies or the protection of human rights and local communities, are on the rise. In particular, privileges granted to foreign investments are increasingly in conflict with efforts to curb climate change and protect the natural world.
Widespread recognition that the ECT is an obstacle to the transition to a low-carbon economy has led its contracting parties to start negotiations on how to effectively “modernize” the treaty to better align it with their investment and climate goals.
What Is IISD Doing to Help?
At IISD, we work with governments, civil society, academia, legal experts, and others to influence the modernization process and develop legal and policy options that will support an expedited phase-out of fossil fuels. This work forms part of our wider mission to ensure that investment law and policy help to facilitate rather than impede progress toward achieving global sustainable development goals.
Together, we seek to break down the legal barriers that prevent countries from pursuing ambitious actions to protect our planet.
You might also be interested in
United We Leave or Divided We Stay? Why it’s time for the EU to speak with one voice regarding the Energy Charter Treaty
After a written procedure that was finalized on Friday July 7, the European Commission formally recommended a coordinated EU withdrawal from the Energy Charter Treaty. What does this mean for climate action?
Bruxelles propose une sortie à l’échelle de l’UE du traité sur la Charte de l’énergie, considéré comme contraire au Green Deal
La Commission européenne a formellement proposé un retrait « coordonné et ordonné » du traité sur la Charte de l’énergie. La législation proposée, dévoilée vendredi après-midi après des jours de spéculation, verrait l’Union européenne et ses États membres quitter le traité controversé en même temps, évitant le chaos d’avoir des pays individuels suivant leur propre chemin. L’Allemagne, la France, l’Espagne, les Pays-Bas et la Pologne faisaient partie de ceux qui avaient précédemment annoncé leur intention de se retirer de manière unilatérale, à l’instar de l’Italie, qui a quitté la convention en 2016.
Brussels tables EU-wide exit from the Energy Charter Treaty, considered at odds with the Green Deal
The European Commission has formally proposed a "coordinated and orderly" withdrawal from the Energy Charter Treaty. The proposed legislation, unveiled on Friday afternoon after days of speculation, would see the European Union and its member states leave the controversial treaty at the same time, avoiding the chaos of having individual countries going their own way.
EU moves to quit energy investment treaty
The European Union on Friday moved to pull the plug on the bloc's membership in the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) — an investor protection pact that's seen as hampering decarbonization efforts.