Environmental Goods and Services Negotiations at the WTO: Lessons from multilateral environmental agreements and ecolabels for breaking the impasse
This analysis looks for paths to progress in the WTO's stalled negotiations on environmental goods and services—a set of talks that is frequently cited as trade policy's natural contribution to climate change objectives.
It surveys the experience of a number of multilateral environmental agreements—The Rotterdam Convention (Prior Informed Consent or PIC), the Stockholm Convention (Persistent Organic Pollutants or POPs) and Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora—and ecolabels (looking at coffee, fisheries and the Energy Star label) for helpful lessons.
Focusing on environmental goods, the analysis begins by creating a taxonomy that allows different treatments for fundamentally different sorts of goods. Type I goods are those, like efficient washers, that are relatively green in their end use or disposal. Type III goods are those that are relatively environmentally friendly in their manner of production, like organic agricultural products. And Type II goods are those that are designed for environmental improvement or natural resource management, such as equipment to contain oil spills.
On the basis of the analysis, the paper makes six recommendations:
Start from first principles (enunciate an environmental objective);
Refer to standards created outside the WTO, where they exist (most relevant for Types I and II);
Where standards do not exist, go slowly (elaborate criteria for "acceptable" standards that may be created in the future and look to non-standards-based lists for Type II goods);
Build in flexibility (for example, so that countries can lodge limited reservations for specific goods);
Base it on science (establish and use technical bodies); and
Build in special and differential treatment.
You might also be interested in
Toolkit for Monitoring, Evaluation, and Learning for National Adaptation Plan Processes
This toolkit provides practical guidance for the development and continuous improvement of MEL systems for national adaptation plan processes to government teams and practitioners working on adaptation.
ASGM Tailings Management and Reprocessing Governance
This report outlines technical aspects, governance frameworks, and policy recommendations for artisanal and small-scale gold mining (ASGM) tailings management and reprocessing.
A Scan of Natural Infrastructure Approaches
A scan of communities in Canada that are successfully implementing natural infrastructure to help deliver municipal services.
Climate Adaptation and Protected Areas Initiative: Nature-based solutions for climate adaptation (infographic)
Climate change impacts greatly affect ecosystems and the communities who depend on them. Nature-based solutions for adaptation (NbS) can play a vital role in helping people and biodiversity build resilience to climate risks. Learn more about what effective NbS for adaptation are and their practical application across different ecosystems to strengthen their resilience.