English Français

Key Message

Responsible, inclusive and transparent governance forms the cornerstone of the sustainable design and implementation of voluntary standards initiatives. By facilitating good governance across initiatives, the SMART initiative aims to improve the efficiency of, and access to, standards-based markets.

Standards and Voluntary Initiatives

Ensuring participatory and inclusive governance

What's New in Standards and Voluntary Initiatives?

  • The “State of Sustainability Initiatives Review 2010: Sustainability and Transparency” (PDF - 7.6 MB)
    As one of the State of Sustainability Initiatives (SSI) Implementing Partners, IISD, along with the Sustainable Commodity Initiative and Swiss State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO), is pleased to announce the release of their latest report "State of Sustainability Initiatives Review 2010: Sustainability and Transparency" on Nov. 17 in Berne, Switzerland. The SSI Review will be released at a launch during the Trade Standards Practitioner's Network's Conference on Standards for a Sustainable Agriculture and the Mitigation of Climate Change being held at the Kursaal Bern Hotel.

    The SSI Review represents the most up-to-date and comprehensive overview of the market trends and system characteristics of major voluntary sustainability standards and initiatives in the forestry, coffee, cocoa, tea and banana sectors. The review provides information on the market performance, governance, criteria coverage and implementation practices of key initiatives (such as Fairtrade Labelling Organizations International, Forest Stewardship Council, Program for the Endorsement of Forest Certification, Rainforest Alliance, UTZ Certified, International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements, GLOBALGAP, Sustainable Forestry Initiative, Social Accountability 8000, and 4C Association). The SSI Review is an important tool for the strategic planning of businesses, policy makers and other stakeholders seeking to build more sustainable supply chains. For more information on SSI, please click here.

Standards and other criteria-based voluntary initiatives set rules for production and trade. Where voluntary rules-based systems integrate sustainable development objectives, participatory, inclusive, impartial and transparent governance form a pre-requisite for effective and credible application. To date, voluntary standards have shown a great deal of flexibility and ingenuity in attempting to meet these objectives in the international context. At the same time, the diversity of different structures and systems has remained relatively opaque to most stakeholders, including public policy-makers. Moreover, the fact that many such initiatives are often born out of small groups of collaborating partners can threaten their impartiality and the ability of other stakeholders to exercise input and influence. As a form of "de facto" trade policy, voluntary standards need, above all, to ensure participatory and inclusive governance in their design. The promotion of good governance among standards initiatives forms a key priority for IISD's SMART initiative.

Good governance and design are, in part, about ensuring the appropriate distribution of obligations and responsibilities; costs and benefits. To date, however, there is very little cross-initiative information or comparisons of the impacts of different standards initiatives. As a means for promoting transparency in governance and, ultimately, maximum efficiency in the application of standards-based initiatives, the SMART initiative is promoting rigorous science-based analysis and impact assessment of such initiatives. By promoting greater clarity and credibility in the science behind supply chain approaches, IISD seeks to leverage maximum impact and benefits from voluntary initiative and complementary government policy.

Contents