[ Developing Ideas Digest ][ IISDnet Contents ]

About Di Digest | Back Issues | Mailing List | Email DI | On Line Features 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
LitScan | Press Review

Further Readings on Common Security

Mail & Guardian
(South Africa)

Thumbs Up!
It's Time We Took Back Our Water by Eddie Koch October 13, 1995

A thoughtful and considerate analysis of the reasons underlying South Africa's water crisis, with useful lessons for other regions. The writer argues that outdated government policies have made water an even more contested resource than land - and that laissez-faire management should be replaced with greater state control and planning. Otherwise, he cautions, the country's mighty rivers might just as well be sewers.



Maclean's Magazine
Thumbs Up!
China's Challenge by Thomas Homer-Dixon September 4, 1995

A refreshing piece of journalism that analyses China's national security from the rare perspective of the environment. At a time when most press types write about China in the clichéd terms of an 'economic miracle', the author argues that the world's most populous country is more aptly described as a seething cauldron of population pressures, social inequities and resource shortages.



Far Eastern Economic Review
Thumbs Up!
Soldiers and Civilians Vie for Command by Rodney Tasker, J. Mcbeth and Bertil Lintner January 18, 1996

In Asia, military might is slowly giving way to democracy and economic development. The coverage com-pares the trend in three countries - Burma, Indonesia and Thailand. As generals live out the dying days of once-great army glory, the Review concludes that Chairman Mao's dictum that power grows out of the barrel of a gun is taking on a distinctly dated tone in Asia.



Atlantic Monthly
Thumbs Up!
The Coming Anarchy by Robert D. Kaplan February 1994

An apocalyptic vision of nations under siege by environmental insecurities. If the intention is to shock readers, the article succeeds brilliantly. If the idea is to offer up positive suggestions for avoiding conflict, the piece falls short. Perhaps it is the tone that is odd - still bogged down in old-style ideas of military security.

Time Magazine
Thumbs Down!
Playing the Power Game by Axel Krause May 20, 1996

A perfectly well-written piece of rubbish. The security of Europe is defined solely in terms of its military strength - and its ability to match the USA in pistol-pointing. Chairman Mao's dictum is wholeheartedly endorsed and a "strong, viable European base" is taken to be the obvious goal of any thinking European.


Thumbs Up
Eureka! Pretty Polished
Thumbs down!
A few Holes



Virtual Ideas
Coverage of water politics in Southern Africa